AI Retirement Advice: What It Can’t Know About You
So how good is AI retirement advice?
Can AI retirement advice be trusted?
In this video, we look at why relying on AI chatbots for personalized financial information often leads to errors.
Tom shares where AI is genuinely helpful, where it can slip, and a simple “New Jersey test” you can try yourself.
A few weeks ago, my router died, and I asked an AI chatbot to walk me through setting up the new one. It was extremely confident, very detailed, and patient for hours. It also never asked the one question that mattered, and that cost me the whole afternoon.
It got me thinking: if AI can miss something that simple about your house, how good is AI retirement advice going to be?
In this week’s video, I cover:
- Where AI is a genuinely useful tool
- Three places AI retirement advice can slip
- A simple “New Jersey test” you can try with any AI tool
- The one thing AI can’t know about you
If you live at the Jersey Shore and want someone who will ask about your whole picture, start at mullooly.net.
AI Retirement Advice: What It Can’t Know About You – Links
Catch all our Mullooly Asset videos here
Subscribe to the Mullooly Asset YouTube Channel
Watch this episode (“AI Retirement Advice – Does It KNOW You?”) on our YouTube Channel
AI Retirement Advice: What It Can’t Know About You – Transcript
A few weeks ago, my router at home reached the end of its life. It conked out.
So I bought a new one, and I asked an AI chatbot to walk me through setting it up – since there weren’t any instructions included.
And for several hours, it was very confident and told me exactly what to plug in and where.
There was really just one problem.
We have two modems in our house. And the whole time, I was hooking everything up to the wrong modem.
The AI never asked.
It only figured it out when I finally told it what was going on. Then we had to backtrack every step and start over.
Here’s my question: If AI can miss something that simple about your house, how good is AI retirement advice going to be?
If you’re new here, my name is Tom Mullooly.
I own a financial planning and investment advisory firm here in Wall Township, New Jersey. And I work alongside my three sons, who are all certified financial planners, just like me.
Here’s the point about AI retirement advice.
AI only knows what you tell it. It can’t see what you see.
It doesn’t know what you know – or what you’ve been through.
So unless you give it everything, you’re going to be getting a generic answer.
And it’s going to sound very confident when it gives you that answer.
I’m not here to knock the technology. It can be really helpful.
It’s great for learning the vocabulary.
It’s great for learning the lingo.
Ask it to explain a required minimum distribution or what a Roth conversion is, and you’ll probably get a really nice “plain English” kind of answer.
Here’s where AI retirement advice can slip:
First, it can be right over here, but wrong over there.
An attorney we know who specializes in elder law recently shared this story.
One of his clients asked AI a Medicaid question.
The answer that AI provided was correct in some states – but not correct here in New Jersey.
Second, rules change.
Tax rules, contribution limits, deadlines.
Artificial intelligence may not know which year it’s working from.
For goodness sakes, sometimes it can’t even tell you what day it is.
Third, push back once in a while…..and just watch what happens.
These AI tools are built to be agreeable.
Tell one, “Are you sure? I think that’s wrong,” and many of them will cave right away,
“Oh, I’m sorry. You’re right,” even when the first answer they gave….. may have been correct.
Here’s a simple test:
Ask your question, then reply, “I don’t think that’s right for New Jersey.”
Watch whether it explains itself….. or if it just caves.
If it caves, it wasn’t standing on any facts.
It was just trying to please you.
One more thing, and this is a compliance matter: please don’t paste your statements, your account numbers, your Social Security number into AI in any way, shape, or form.
I think the biggest takeaway today is this: the problem with AI retirement advice is pretty simple.
It doesn’t know you.
It doesn’t know your health.
It doesn’t know your family.
It doesn’t know about your pension.
It doesn’t know the retirement account your spouse forgot about.
It doesn’t know about the child support you’re supposed to be paying.
It doesn’t know how you’re going to feel the next time the market drops 15%.
Those kind of details change the answer, just like that “second modem” changed mine.
This is what we do here. If you live at the Jersey Shore and you’d like to talk your situation through with someone who will actually ask about your whole picture, you can reach us at mullooly.net.
A good planner asks you questions before giving you answers.
And sometimes the most valuable thing we can tell you is, “No, that’s not right for you, and here’s why.”
So use AI retirement advice to get smarter, to learn the lingo.
Try that New Jersey test that I mentioned, and then check it with someone who knows you.
I mentioned that rules change.
They change all the time.
If you’re curious how to plan when the rules keep moving, watch this video next.





